Review: Hilda and the Midnight Giant by Luke Pearson

Hilda and the Midnight Giant by Luke Pearson. Nobrow Press, 2012. Currently available.

Genre: Middle Grade Graphic Novel

13022038Face Value: Such an enchanting cover. There’s magic in this image. Hilda is a quirky looking little girl, and her eyes tell us that she’s discovered something amazing. This cover was so intriguing that it motivated me to track down a copy of the book.

Does it break the slate? Yes. Hilda has the gift of being young, and her youth and open-minded nature allow her to see the right solution in a tough situation – even though it’s not a solution that is easy for her. She is feisty yet compassionate, which is a really nice blend of character traits. I see a lot of Slatebreaking girl characters who are admirably bold, but they are often so caught up in their own forward movement that they overlook the feelings of others. Hilda is the antidote to that. Hilda connects with those around her, even if they have little in common.

Who would we give it to? If you know any girls who have active imaginations, and maybe even invisible friends, this is a great book for them. It’s the perfect book to read inside of a blanket fort by flashlight.

Review: Hilda and her mother live in a delightfully secluded valley and treasure their idyllic home. It is a great upset to their lives when they begin to experience vandalism and bullying from their neighbors – their tiny, invisible neighbors. Hilda’s mom considers moving out of their beloved home when she receives a job offer in the big city. Reluctant to leave the home that she loves, Hilda gets creative and tries to find reasons why she and her mom can stay where they are.

Hilda lives in a world that is a little bit supernatural. It is a fantasy world where there are tiny invisible elvish-type beings, as well as giants, and a whole other menagerie of unusual beings. Other than the population of fantastical creatures, however, the world operates in a way very similar to our own. Bureaucracy clogs up the pipeline of progress and adults say things that they don’t mean to get what they want. Hilda doesn’t understand why everything has to be so complicated. She just wants to enjoy the beauty of the world and make sure that the other beings in her neighborhood are content, too.

Because Hilda is willing to talk to anyone or anything, she makes some friendships that help her as she explores her little valley. She meets one of the invisible beings and signs a form that allows her to see them all – and she learns that her house is blocking major developments in their tiny city. I loved how Pearson illustrated Hilda’s ability to see what the other humans could not. It reminded me of a grander metaphor – that children can often see the things that we adults cannot because our vision has been clouded by years of disappointment and mistrust. Hilda can see past all of that, and her awareness of other people’s needs grows exponentially. She gets that she can’t always have what she wants, especially if her desires are less important than the greater good. I love that Hilda has this level of civic awareness, even as a very young girl.

I am sure that everyone who has reviewed this book has said this, but it bears repeating: anyone who likes the work of Miyazaki will totally dig Hilda and the Midnight Giants. Pearson seems to be just getting started in this simple yet charming adventure. There will be more Hilda books on the way, and I hope to see her character grow in awareness and nuance. She already shows signs of greatness through her empathy and emotional intelligence. I suspect Hilda has some more adventures coming, and I will definitely be reading along as she embarks on her journeys.

Reviewed from a library copy.

Posted in Graphic Novels, Middle Grade, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Janie Face to Face by Caroline B. Cooney

Janie Face to Face by Caroline B. Cooney. Delacore Press, 2013. Currently Available.

Genre: Contemporary Realistic Fiction (the realism though, is debatable)

Janie Face to FaceFace Value: Why are you trapped in a mirror Janie? I mean Jennie? I mean…is it the TWO SIDES OF YOUR EXISTENCE TRAPPED BEHIND SOMETHING? How profound. But seriously, this Shadowy-Trapped-Bodies series of re-issues makes me downright nostalgic for the way more literal original cover art.

Does it Break the Slate? NO! NO WAY! Not in a million years! Janie is a pathetic and whiny brat who is totally thoughtless of everybody around her, all the other female characters are vapid or evil or both, and all need protecting, and marriage is presented as the magical solution to all potential problems ever in the world. I haven’t read the earlier books since childhood, so I am not sure if the earlier books had real Slatebreaking qualities. But they could not possibly have been as bad as this one.

Who would we give it to? Nobody. Seriously. If you are feeling nostalgic for the original series, re-read the first one, or watch the Lifetime movie with Kellie Martin in a red wig, or buy a carton of milk. Do not read this book. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Revenge of the Girl with the Great Personality by Elizabeth Eulberg

Revenge of the Girl with the Great Personality by Elizabeth Eulberg. Scholastic, 2013. Available March 1.

Genre: YA Realistic Fiction

GP-front-675x1024Face Value: The lipstick-written title has been done before, but it’s fitting in this case. This book is all about the ways in which we mask ourselves with artificial means. It’s also a little bit rebellious – using the lipstick the put into words something that has been hidden. Yep, totally appropriate for this book.

Does it break the slate? Tough call. Lexi veers from one end of the spectrum (hating artificial beauty and eschewing makeup and fashion) to the other (spending hours on her appearance daily) throughout the book. She ultimately comes to a middle-ground stance regarding makeup, clothes, and what they mean for her – but it’s not an easy journey to get there. Although not all of the choices Lexi makes are Slatebreaking, I think she’s an example of a female character that would feel authentic to most teen readers. It’s not easy to make a feminist choice – especially in a small, conservative high school. Lexi can help readers feel more at ease with their own conflicting ideas about appearance. She’s an example of a young woman who learns through trial and error and grows stronger through those experiences.

Who would we give it to? This is a book for sisters who feel overshadowed. I’ve you know any sisters who wish they could shine as bright as their siblings, they will find a friend in this book. It’s also a thought provoking book for girls who feel awkward about their appearance. That was definitely me in high school, and I know I’m not the only one who attempted to define myself through clothes and makeup and ended up looking like I was trying too hard. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Review: Graffiti Moon by Cath Crowley

Graffiti Moon by Cath Crowley. Knopf Books for Young Readers, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Contemporary Realistic Fiction

Graffiti Moon 2Face Value: I actually listened to the audio book of this one, so I didn’t spend as much time with the cover as I usually might, but I like it quite a bit – the silhouettes and the colors do a great job of evoking the book’s tone.

Does it Break the Slate? Oooh, yes. It does. This is a romance, straight-up, and it’s a romance in which two people find each other, and fall in love because of who they really are. Both of our protagonists are flawed, tough individuals, who are trying to figure out who they are, and, by the end of the book have both figured out a little more through each other.

Who would we give it to? There are so many lovers of YA romance from the likes of Stephanie Perkins, Sarah Dessen, and other wonderful writers – they might not originally be drawn to this book, but I think they’d love it. It has all the right romantic elements, with it’s own totally unique spin. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

Review: Crewel by Gennifer Albin

Crewel by Gennifer Albin. Farrar Straus Giroux, 2012. Currently available.

Genre: YA Fantasy/Dystopia

imagesFace Value: The ethereal strands of colorful light evoke the visual landscape of the unusual dystopic world that Albin has created. Of course, there is the problem of a sexualized young female face on the cover. It accurately reflects the way that female characters are ritually sexualized in the story – but it’s still not a great way to present a potentially powerful female character.

Does it break the slate? To be determined. This is the first book in a series, and Adelice is a character who wields great influence because her unusual talents for manipulating the forces that control the world of Arras. However, Adelice doesn’t use her talent wisely in this book – she is impulsive and often confused as she uncovers the layers of deceit that surround her. She also falls easily into emotional states in which she cannot muster the energy to fight back. I wouldn’t call her a Slatebreaking character yet, but she has the potential to grow into one throughout this series.

Who would we give it to? Readers who are still digging the dystopian trend will enjoy the creatively constructed, futuristic world in Crewel.

Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , , | 1 Comment

Review: Vessel by Sarah Beth Durst

Vessel by Sarah Beth Durst. Margaret K. McElderry, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Fantasy

VesselFace Value:  I respect this cover. While it doesn’t necessarily scream to me from bookstore shelves, once I was reading the book I found myself totally drawn to it. The girl looks like Liyana is described, right down to the clothing and it hints at the story without giving anything away.

Does it Break the Slate? YES, definitely yes. This book is Slate-shattering on a couple of different levels. First, we have a whole host of fascinating, powerful female characters, starting with our indomitable heroine Liyana, including the totally different vessels Raan and Pia and even the goddess Bayla all give us different amazing women to appreciate. But even the bigger ideas of the book, about identity and faith and what we deserve are Slatebreaking ideals that are given serious thought in this book, challenging the reader to think about these big issues from multiple perspectives.

Who would we give it to? Any fantasy lovers with series-fatigue, longing for a really good stand-alone piece of storytelling, this is the book for you. The rich world-building and honest characterizations will appeal to both serious fantasy readers and fans of contemporary realism. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Review: Hattie Ever After by Kirby Larson

Hattie Ever After by Kirby Larson. Random House, 2013. Available February 12, 2013.

Genre: Middle grade historical fiction

imagesFace Value: Hattie is looking good! Immediately her outfit cues us in to the era in which we will be reading, and the streetcars behind her lend a nod to the San Francisco setting. I think this is a prime example of a historical fiction cover that looks appropriately contemporary – young readers won’t think it looks “dated” – but still acknowledges the time period in which the book is set.

Does it break the slate? In this sequel to Hattie Big Sky, Hattie Inez Brooks continues to be the strong, independent woman we grew to know and love when she was homesteading on the Montana prairie. The interesting contrast in these books is that when working on her homestead, Hattie was mostly alone. She spent many hours a day puzzling through her challenges, and her failures affected her in a private way. Now that Hattie is living and working in San Francisco, there are dozens more people to witness her missteps – and she has to cope with her own misfortunes differently. It is a pleasure to read about how this smart, Slatebreaking young woman evolves in a different city.

Who would we give it to? Anyone who loved Hattie Big Sky should run out and get a copy of this book. I would also recommend it for young readers who are interested in writing as a career. Hattie forges her own writing career in this novel, and excellent tidbits of writing advice are woven throughout the story.

I noticed that this book felt a little more “YA” than the first. It is still appropriate for middle grade readers, but Hattie is approaching a more adult time in her life when she has to make choices about career and marriage. Slightly older or more mature middle grade level readers might enjoy that quality in this book. Continue reading

Posted in Middle Grade, Reviews | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Review: Scarlet by A.C. Gaughen

Scarlet by A.C. Gaughen. Bloomsbury, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Historical Fiction / Retelling

ScarletUS.inddFace Value: I’m neutral on this cover, which doesn’t have any major flaws but is boring. Sure, the girl looks appropriately androgynous and is a fair match for the description of Scarlet in the book (if a little more vacant in the eyes), but if I hadn’t already heard good things about it I would never have grabbed it off a library shelf.

Does it Break the Slate? Mostly yes. There is a ton of Slatebreaking in this novel, what with our tough protagonist who disguises herself as a boy and fights better than most of them. And there’s some really excellent analysis of what it was like to be a woman in this time (not great). However, even our heroes are not exempt from this societal ills of the time, and I had a real problem with the way even some of our good characters like Robin and John talk to and treat women, without any kind of repercussion or understanding.  

Who would we give it to? Definitely anyone who is fond of these stories is going to find something to enjoy here, and I actually think there might be a real audience in The Hunger Games crowd as a book about another fierce young woman who knows her way around her weapons. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , | 1 Comment

DIY Reading Bingo

Sometimes I find myself in a reading rut. I love YA and middle grade books, especially realistic and historical fiction. These books make up the bulk of my reading. It’s great for me because I enjoy these books, and it’s great for the blog because there are always new and interesting books to review.

But I have to confess that I occasionally long to break out of the routine. Whether it’s a new creative non-fiction book that I’ve heard about on NPR or a book that I want to read for work, I have the urge to branch out with my reading practices. I have often suppressed that urge by reminding myself of the endless shelves of Slatebreaking books that exist in the world – and I want to read them all! Although it has kept my reading focused, it certainly has not helped me be a diverse reader. I read as many books as I can, but within a narrow scope of genres and target audiences.

I set a goal for myself in 2013: to expand my reading habits. Of course, I am still going to read as many Slatebreaking books as I can. These books are the fuel that stokes my desire to read. However, I feel that I need to intersperse types of books that I don’t usually read, and motivate myself to read books by authors that I have not explored. Continue reading

Posted in Miscellaneous | Tagged , , , , , | 4 Comments

Review: A Wrinkle In Time – The Graphic Novel adapted and illustrated by Hope Larson

A Wrinkle in Time (the graphic novel) adapted and illustrated by Hope Larson from the novel by Madeleine L’Engle. Margaret Ferguson Books, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Science Fiction Graphic Novel

Wrinkle in TimeFace Value: Graphic novels have an obvious advantage when it comes to cover art. It would be really weird not to use the artwork from the creator. And so, since the art in this book is good, we get an absolutely beautiful cover. I love the way we see our three heroes faces and silhouettes, the cosmos in the background, and the overall feeling of something bigger than ourselves that the images convey. There’s literally only one downside, and it’s featured on the back cover. Seriously – you couldn’t find a better choice to blurb your book than James Patterson?* L’Engle – and Larson – deserve better.

Does it Break the Slate? Because this is an adaptation, I want to talk about the Slatebreaking on two different levels. First, Madeleine L’Engle wrote one of the quintessential Slatebreaking characters of all time when she gave us Meg Murray. Angry and impulsive and brilliant and loving, Meg has been shattering slates across dimensions of time and space for 50 years. And in this beautiful graphic adaptation, Hope Larson gives visuals to this character and her story in a way that captures every agonizing emotional moment and every stunning instance of bravery with remarkable subtlety.

Who would we give it to? I think of this graphic novel adaptation much in the same way that I think about the stage production of A Wrinkle in Time that the theatre company I work for is putting up onstage this spring. I love the book, and nothing is ever going to replace the experience I had of reading that novel as a ten year old. However, I think that great art inspires other art, and I love adaptations of books that I love. I’m recommending that everyone I know who loved Wrinkle go see the stage play at Childsplay in a couple of months and I feel the same way about this graphic novel version. Read it to be reminded how much you love the original, and to be inspired by another artist’s terrific work.

*True fact. I recently de-friended someone on Goodreads (someone I know in real life!) because they gave five stars to a James Patterson novel. Continue reading

Posted in Middle Grade, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , , , | 6 Comments