Review: Burn for Burn by Jenny Han & Siobhan Vivian

Burn for Burn by Jenny Han & Siobhan Vivian. Simon & Schuster, 2012. Currently available.

Genre: YA contemporary realistic fiction.

13406425Face Value: The girls on this cover have whole bodies, which is a great thing. As an Instagram lover, I’m also digging the funky filter applied to the photo. But when I look closer, I am extremely bothered by the fact that the blonde timid girl is the central character in the photograph. The brunette and the Asian girl are teetering on the edge of the cover. I found Kat and Lillia to be more essential to the story, in that they were the girls who decided to move forward with the plan that is central to the plot, so I feel that they deserve more cover space than Mary. Buuuuuuut I guess putting the blonde character front and center is a marketing choice.

Does it break the slate? The jury is still out on this one. The young women in this story take action to exact revenge upon those who have hurt them. They reject passivity in favor of making social change. But the ways in which they enact their revenge rely on the same dirty tactics of their oppressors – so is that truly Slatebreaking? I’m going to wait for the next two books (it’s the first in a trilogy!) before I draw any final conclusions.

Who would we give it to? This is excellent realistic contemporary fiction, and would be a great book for anyone who loves that genre or needs a palate cleanser from the constant stream of dystopia/paranormal fiction filling the shelves. As someone who sometimes ponders ways in which I could have better handled the people who bothered me in high school, I found this book both cathartic and a bit disturbing. If I had read this when I was in high school, I suspect I may have gotten some bold ideas about how to prank those who disrespected me…but I never would have had the guts to carry it out. I can see the value in sharing this book with anyone who feels bullied, ignored, or wronged, because they can connect with the three girls at the heart of the story. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: The Cavendish Home for Boys and Girls by Claire Legrand

The Cavendish Home for Boys and Girls by Claire Legrand. Simon & Schuster, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Horror

Face Value: While this cover isn’t quite a scene that we see in the book, it captures the tone quite nicely. And the inclusion of both Victoria and Lawrence on the cover subtly suggests that this book will work for boys and girls, without pretending that it has nothing to do with girls so boys will read it. The colors, the font, and the particular style of the illustration is contemporary and creepy and a good fit for the book.

Does it Break the Slate? YES! Victoria Wright, you are an amazing Slatebreaker, right up there with Matilda and Coraline, the young women whose stories inspired yours. But don’t be fooled – Victoria is also completely her own character, both fastidious and heroic, who takes down a villain and rescues her classmates through both her own strengths and flaws.

Who would we give it to? As I mentioned above, there are beloved children’s stories that clearly influence Legrand’s writing. Don’t worry – that’s not any indication that this story is anything less than original. But readers of Roald Dahl and Neil Gaiman will find a lot to love in this book. Continue reading

Posted in Middle Grade, Reviews | Tagged , , , , | 2 Comments

Review: Flirting in Italian by Lauren Henderson

Flirting in Italian by Lauren Henderson. Delacorte Press, 2012. Currently available.

Genre: YA contemporary realistic fiction

Flirting-in-ItalianFace Value: Two cut-off bodies do not win this cover any points. The Vespa is charming, but that girl is wearing the weirdest outfit. I would be wary about wearing that skirt while straddling anything because…well…I guess I just prefer a little more coverage of my undercarriage. But I could forgive the skirt if she was wearing cute shoes. Instead, my eyes have to cope with the hideous combination of argyle socks and blue boots. Who styled this cover shoot? And what was the inspiration? Violet is a character who appreciates unique fashion, but her style isn’t described as anything close to what is represented in this picture.

Does it break the slate? Oh no. Not even close. The girls in this novel have the potential to be so confident and terrific, but they turn into pandering messes when a cute boy shows up. I was frustrated by the vacillating tendencies of the characters. One minute they had smart dialogue and lots of potential, and the next minute they were as shallow as a puddle. Every female character that made an appearance in this book was disappointing. It sounds like I’m exaggerating, but I’m not. I just made a list of all of the female characters and each one was a broadly drawn stereotype.

Who would we give it to? I think that the cover and the setting would appeal to fans of Anna and the French Kiss, but ultimately they would be left unsatisfied. Put this book back on the shelf and find some other great YA European adventure realistic fiction to give. 13 Little Blue Envelopes would be an excellent alternative. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Amelia Anne is Dead and Gone by Kat Rosenfield

Amelia Anne is Dead and Gone by Kat Rosenfield. Dutton Books, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Mystery

Face Value: It’s tonally appropriate, and creepy, that’s for sure. But an obscured image of a dead girl with a flower between her legs? No thank you.

Does it Break the Slate? NO. No it doesn’t. There are good qualities to this book, but none of them involve the strength of its female characters. Becca is a character in transition – but instead of rising to the occasion, she wallows in her uncertainty. Amelia is moving towards pursuing her dreams – and gets killed for it.

Who would we give it to? I, personally, wouldn’t give this book to anybody. It’s gotten good reviews other places though, so I am certain there is an audience for it somewhere. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , | 3 Comments

The 2012 Slatebreakers Non-Book Book-Related Gift Guide

Yes, that may be the most convoluted gift guide title you will see this holiday season. We’re trying to think outside of the box this year. Obviously we are big fans of giving books as gifts, and many of the books that we have positively reviewed on the site would make excellent gifts when matched with an eager reader. But sometimes your fellow bookworm friends fill up their punch cards at the local bookstore faster than you can keep up. Or they may have a teetering stack of library books that they want to work through. In those situations, what do you give them? I’ve collected a few ideas, and picked up a few more from fellow book lovers.

GimmgGimmeBlog-TellTaleGameFor the young readers who also love a good board game, pick up Tell Tale. This simple game challenges players to create their own stories. Each card has a unique image on it. You draw a card and have to somehow incorporate the concept represented by the image into the story. My niece and nephew love this game, and my niece is a pro at it. She’s really good at working each image into a story. You can also use the cards in different ways – there are other game suggestions included in the tin. This would be a great gift for young readers who are learning about story structure. I think it’s a wonderful game because it puts players in the role of author and reminds us that we have agency in shaping the narratives in our lives. Available from Blue Orange Games.

smash stamp

I can’t be the only one who secretly wishes he or she had pursued a career as a librarian. I have this SMASH date stamp by K & Company, and every time I use it I get to live my circulation desk daydreams. This would be a fun gift to young aspiring librarians or to grownups who dream about being a librarian in their next life.

buffaloFor older board game lovers, this buffalo party game by Tiltfactor isn’t exactly book-related, but it’s definitely Slatebreaking. I’m going to paste the description from the website to show you why: “buffalo was developed as part of a National Science Foundation (NSF) funded project called “Transforming Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math (STEM) For Women and Girls: Reworking Stereotypes & Bias.” The two-year grant has allowed Tiltfactor to develop a number of game designs with additional assistance from the National Girls Collaborative Project, a nationwide organization that wishes to promote gender equity within STEM fields.” That’s so cool. I kind of want to buy buffalo for everyone on my shopping list.

diy-geometric-bookmarksFeeling crafty…and also cheap? These DIY geometric felt bookmarks from How About Orange look really nice and are inexpensive to make. I love crafts that look like they were way more expensive to make then what they actually cost. And these look so upscale, fancy, and architectural. Make a whole set for readers (like me!) who are constantly misplacing bookmarks.

AHFRSOMERVILLESNA300If you have a sewing machine and some basic sewing skills, you can whip up a library tote for little or big readers. (Here’s another version that looks fun to make.) You could also make an e-reader case (tutorials here and here) for friends who prefer to read on their Kindle or Nook. There are some really neat book-print fabrics out there, too, to make a handmade reading-related gift extra special. I like this bookshelf print by Alexander Henry and any of the prints in the Connecting Threads Bookish collection.

Matilda on BroadwayFor theatre enthusiasts looking for live singing and dancing Slatebreakers, the soundtrack for the new Matilda musical is an excellent gift. The song “Naughty” is a pinnacle of musical theatre solos for girl characters. I listen to that soundtrack over and over and sing along at the top of my lungs every time. It also is the pinnacle of Slatebreaking: Matilda is singing about young female heroines who break the rules because they have to craft better endings to their own stories. Instead of the soundtrack, you could give tickets to the real show, which would just be the best gift ever. I know I’m gushing, but I love Matilda the book so much, and to know that it has been transformed into a smart, witty, and delightful stage musical makes me so happy.

616CRd2f-kL._SL160_AA160_If you are gift giving on a budget this year, there’s nothing more practical than the simple gift of a classic composition notebook and a nice pen. How is this Slatebreaking? Well, anytime a woman young or old realizes their own agency in shaping outcomes – whether in the narrative of their life or a fictional narrative of their creation – that’s a Slatebreaking moment.

What else is on your shopping list this year? Tell us what Slatebreaking book and non-book gifts you will be giving!

Posted in Miscellaneous | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Review: Uprising by Margaret Peterson Haddix

Uprising by Margaret Peterson Haddix. Simon & Schuster Books for Young People, 2007. Currently Available.

Genre: Historical Fiction

Face Value: I listened to this book on audio, so I didn’t have as much face time with the cover as I normally would. But this cover is pretty good – I love that the photograph images look authentic, and the factory in the background. The flames make it look a little bit like a Caroline Cooney novel – more melodrama, less historical accuracy – but no one can say its not accurate or effective.

I’m more excited by this paperback edition, which I saw on goodreads, but haven’t seen in the wild anywhere. The illustration nearly always has my vote, and the simplicity of the dress form surrounded by flames is evocative and aesthetically pleasing.

Does it Break the Slate? Oh, wow is this a Slatebreaking book. A lot of the books I’ve read about the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory tragedy, especially the fictional accounts, paint the girls as innocent victims, fallen prey to the exploitation of evil bosses. It’s not that that isn’t true in this story too – everyone who died in the fire was an innocent victim – but this account of what happened at Triangle goes so much deeper. Our story starts far before the fire, and really explores the general strike that happened at Triangle and in other factories before it, what those workers were fighting for, and why they weren’t granted their demands / what the ultimate outcome was. It addresses class privilege, workers rights, immigration, and feminism, alongside a whole host of other topics. And yet, the story is incredibly compelling.

Who would we give it to? This is a gripping account of an already compelling moment in history. It would be an easy recommendation from anyone who loved American Girl or Dear America books and is ready to move on to something a little more complex. It would also be a great pairing with the nonfiction Flesh and Blood So Cheap by Albert Marrin which we reviewed on this blog last year. Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , , , | 3 Comments

Review: First Girl Scout by Ginger Wadsworth

First Girl Scout: The Life of Juliette Gordon Low by Ginger Wadsworth. Clarion Books, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Middle Grade Non-Fiction

Face Value: Ugh. Another headless girl. However, I am a fan of the traditional Girl Scout uniform and the way that the uniform elements were used throughout the book – chapter titles were printed as embroidered badges, the trefoil adorned title pages, and fabrics used in uniforms throughout the years were featured as page backgrounds. So although the cover is not ideal, the overall book design is aesthetically pleasing.

Does it break the slate? Yes, it does. This biography is about a powerhouse of a woman. Juliette Gordon Low managed to generate interest, recruit volunteers, and enroll thousands of young women in the Girl Scouts organization. And although she didn’t do it all herself, it was her passion and advocacy for the organization that kept it going. Her spirit is an admirably Slatebreaking example for any girl who wants to get people interested in something she is passionate about.

Who would we give it to? This is an awesome gift book for current and former Girl Scouts. It would also be a great book for anyone you know who is a Girl Scout troop leader. Continue reading

Posted in Middle Grade, Nonfiction, Reviews | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Unspoken by Sarah Rees Brennan

Unspoken by Sarah Rees Brennan. Random House, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Mystery, Fantasy

Face Value: I like this kind of cover, with the monochrome background and black and gold stenciling. It’s a familiar look in YA covers these days, but it’s one that I like. It also capture the gothic, spooky feeling of the story and means that we don’t have to grimace over a cover that is just Kami’s headless torso or something.

Does it Break the Slate? Unequivocally. Kami is a fierce, smart, driven Slatebreaker and so is her friend group. She’s determined to find out the truth and do the right thing. Plus, Kami’s not the only Slatebreaking character in the book. Brennan’s complicated portrait of female friendships, and how a group of two can be expanded to a group of three is fantastically well crafted.

Who would we give it to? Before I read this book I was hooked because of the multiple comparisons to our beloved Veronica Mars.  A Veronica-like character and story is always something that’s going to appeal to me. Of course, this kind of comparison has let me down before, so I was wary as I started reading. Fortunately, my worries were for nothing. Kami’s similarities to Veronica come from her smart banter, quick wit, pursuit of the truth, and occasional willingness to put herself in danger because of it. The plot is not similar – there’s no father daughter detective agency or anything like that. The tone is similar. And because of that similar tone and equally strong story, Veronica Mars fans will be all over this one.

Continue reading

Posted in Reviews, Young Adult | Tagged , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Review: The Lions of Little Rock by Kristin Levine

The Lions of Little Rock by Kristin Levine. Penguin, 2012. Currently available.

Genre: Middle grade historical fiction.

Face Value: Hurrah! An illustrated cover! I’m happy to see this cover because it is gender neutral and a graceful representation of interracial friendship. It doesn’t really hint at all to the time period of the book. I realize that a publisher may find it advantageous to be ambiguous about the story setting (do historical fiction novels sell fewer copies than contemporary fiction?), but I like to see a hint of the time period in cover illustrations.

Does it break the slate? Yes. Something especially enjoyable about The Lions of Little Rock is that it includes the Slatebreaking journey not only of an adolescent girl, but of her mother as well. The mother-daughter bond grows as both get involved in civic issues. Because of that relationship and the way it develops throughout the book, I think this would be a great book for a family read-along.

Who would we give it to? This is the book for quiet girls. Anyone who is terrified of speaking up and saying the wrong thing, anyone who has to play out conversations in their head before having them, anyone who feels that his or her voice doesn’t matter – they should be reading this book. Continue reading

Posted in Middle Grade, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Splendors and Glooms by Laura Amy Schlitz

Splendors and Glooms by Laura Amy Schlitz. Candlewick, 2012. Currently Available.

Genre: Historical Fiction, Fantasy, Gothic Novel

Face Value: This cover is exquisite. First, the dark colors and brooding artwork perfectly capture the gothic tone of the story. Then, when you look closer, you see the rich fabric of the curtain, and you realize that the two children are actually marionettes. Look up and see the imposing giant hand manipulating their strings. Flip the cover over and see the strung skeleton puppet glancing askew back at you, suggesting something forboding to come. It’s beautiful, tonally appropriate and incredibly creepy. In short, I loved it.

Does it Break the Slate? Yes! This book features three fantastic young protagonists, two girls, all of which are awesome in their own way. From a Slatebreaking point of view, both Clara and Lizzie Rose are young women who are determined to stand up for their own rights, regardless of societal implications for women at the time. In addition to dynamic girl heroes, Splendors and Glooms also pushes its young protagonists to grapple with big picture ideas of class, ethics and power.

Who would we give it to? Here we have another book for the lovers of Victorian orphan fiction! I know I’m not the only one out there. Seriously, if you loved The Wolves of Willoughby Chase and everything like it, this is the book for you. Continue reading

Posted in Middle Grade, Reviews | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments