Review: The Impossible Knife of Memory by Laurie Halse Anderson. Viking, 2014. Currently Available.
Genre: Contemporary Realistic Fiction
Face Value: Beautiful. I am totally here for this cover, which is contemporary and emotionally resonant and also just a lovely piece of art. Excellent work, book designers! I like the title too, but I keep mixing it up in my mind with The Knife of Never Letting Go because they are very similar titles. Extremely different books, but very similar titles.
Does it Break the Slate? For the most part, yes, it really does. Haley is a character who has to be strong and self-protective in really difficult circumstances, and she steps up to remarkable challenges. While she doesn’t always make the “right” choices, she’s also a character who is faced with total uncertainty and high levels of responsibility for the adults in her life in ways that no young person should have to be. Both Haley as a character and the way Laurie Halse Anderson writes about her circumstances add up to an absolutely Slatebreaking piece of writing.
Who would we give it to? I can’t think of another book that deals with the real impact of PTSD on families, especially in a contemporary setting, as this one does. For military families coping with it, or for any family dealing with trauma and recovery, I think that teens would find deep resonance in this book and Haley’s authentically written voice.
Penny and Her Marble by Kevin Henkes. Green Willow Books, 2013. Currently available.
Age Level & Genre: Picture book fiction.
Face Value: It looks like every other Kevin Henkes book, which is to say that it looks very mild and pleasant. There’s nothing wrong with that. Why mess with success?
Does it break the slate? For an introductory reader level picture book, this book handles the issue of right and wrong in an interesting way. Penny has to deal with an ethical dilemma. Although she hems and haws, she ultimately makes the admirable choice. Although she isn’t a Slatebreaker, she is modeling smart decision making skills that any young reader could learn from.
Who would we give it to? New readers who want to practice their reading skills with some familiar characters.
Seven Stories Up by Laurel Snyder. Random House Books for Young Readers, 2014. Available January 28, 2014.
Genre: Time Travel / Historical Fiction
Face Value: I have to admit, I’m a little disappointed in this cover. It’s not that it’s terrible – there is nothing wrong with it, it reflects the story and the characters. But it looks a little dated. And one of the things I think that Laurel Snyder does best is balance the feel of a historical novel with a contemporary writing style. This cover reflects the first without the benefit of the second.
Does it Break the Slate? Yes, absolutely! I loved Bigger Than a Breadbox when it came out and I thought that this companion novel was such a lovely balance to that piece. Annie is a smart and thoughtful protagonist and Molly’s stubbornness and self-determination makes her a great supporting character. Both girls go through a Slatebreaking journey over the course of the narrative and the ultimate resolution was surprisingly satisfying.
Who would we give it to? Laurel Snyder clearly takes inspiration from classic fantasy writers like E. Nesbit and Edward Eager, writing the type of story where an ordinary young person stumbles upon a surprising magic in an everyday object. The young people then have to learn the rules of that magic, enjoy its benefits and worry over its potential danger. Ultimately that magic leads to a journey of self-awareness (but not, it is important to note, necessarily a moral lesson). Like Ms. Snyder, I loved these books when I was growing up, as did many others. I think that builds a wide audience for her fiction – both for young people who have already discovered Nesbit and Eager’s work and want more, and for young people who will enjoy this type of novel with a more contemporary feel.
Anatomy of a Boyfriend by Daria Snadowsky. Delacorte, 2007. Currently Available.
Age Level & Genre: YA Realistic Fiction
Face Value: This is a great cover. It’s simple and funny. Unfortunately, the book didn’t really live up to the potential of the cover.
Does it break the slate? No. I was so disappointed. Dominique had a ton of potential, but every time she could have made a bold decision she acted whiny and immature instead.
Who would we give it to? I might recommend it to a high school student now, but there are so many books out there with more interesting female characters that this title would be low on my list.
No Place Like Oz by Danielle Paige. Harper Collins, 2013. Currently Available as an e-book.
Genre: Fantasy / Retelling
Face Value: This cover strikes a nice balance for a retelling. The original imagery is there (the yellow brick road, the Wizard’s balloon), but the contemporary style gives a clear sense that this is a different kind of Oz. And I like it.
Does it Break the Slate? Surprisingly? Yes! As this is a prequel novella that sets the scene for Paige’s upcoming (and terrifically titled) Dorothy Must Die, this is the book that’s supposed to give us the backstory on how our beloved Dorothy Gale can become Oz’s next great supervillain. (I love this premise, btw) And Paige does a nice job of establishing exactly how that might happen, without sacrificing the integrity of the character or Baum’s original story. What makes it a Slatebreaking story is the fact that Dorothy’s descent into wickedness is not only oddly empathetic, it comes as a direct result of her sense of loss when she has to return to Kansas where her options seem suddenly far more limited than they did in Oz, where she was a powerful hero. I’m excited to see Paige continue this commentary as the series goes on.
Who would we give it to? This one is easy. Find a girl in a Wicked t-shirt humming “Defying Gravity” between classes. She’ll devour this. Continue reading
You may recall a time in early 2013 when I set a goal for myself involving a “Reading Bingo” card. This was in the halcyon days of the year, months before I even considered some of the big transitions that were going to take place in 2013. Ah, the bliss of ignorance. Continue reading
The Nightmare Affair by Mindee Arnett. Tor Teen, 2013. Currently Available.
Face Value: I picked up this book because the silhouette style cover reminded me of Sarah Rees Brennan’s Unspoken, which I loved. I like this cover art quite a bit and I think that it fits the book, but it does look pretty familiar in the landscape of YA covers lately. It’s pretty, but I don’t know how much it will stand out on a shelf.
Does it Break the Slate? While this novel isn’t covering any new ground, broken slate wise, I definitely liked reading a book about a magical boarding school with a girl in the leading role. Dusty is a solid heroine and the male characters aren’t presented as built-in rescuers or protectors. Bonus Slatebreaking points are included for the supporting character of Selene, Dusty’s roommate who is a siren who is taking an active stance against the sexualization and objectification of sirens. More of this in future books please!
Who would we give it to? It’s about a magical boarding school. Give it to the reader who insists that the Harry Potter series is the only thing they really want to read. It also has a magical murder investigation, so I think it would be a safe recommendation to mystery readers too. Continue reading